Friday 23 November 2018

Engineers are Potential Terrorists?

Ethics in Engineering
Image Source: www.tutorialspoint.com

After 9-11 tragedy, Muslims have always been associated with terrorism especially in the western media. Their Islamic faith has been put to blame even though there are also cases involving terrorists from other religions. But another pattern also emerged instead of religion factor: most of them have science and engineering educational background.

According to research by Gambetta, a renowned sociologist at the European University Institute in Italy, and Steffen Hertog, an associate professor at the London School of Economics, more than twice as many members of violent Islamist organisations have engineering degrees as have degrees in Islamic studies. Another possible factor especially for those who hail from Middle Eastern and North African countries as well as from migrant communities, people with engineering backgrounds encounter tougher experience in getting stable jobs due to economic and political situations [1].

Based on studies conducted on more than 4,000 political radicals operating across the Muslim world and in the West in reference [2], engineers have been found to be dominating every jihadist group worldwide. Sharing the same observation as [1], the surplus of graduates in countries compared to small demands of labour could lead to frustration.

Some of the examples of terrorists with engineering background such as in February 2010, Joseph Andrew Stack, a software engineer, crashed his plane into I.R.S. offices in Austin, Tex. The following month, John Patrick Bedell, an engineering grad student, opened fire at an entrance to the Pentagon. In early May 2010, Faisal Shahzad (bachelor of science in computer science and engineering) was arrested at Kennedy Airport for a failed attempt to set off a bomb in Times Square. In the same month, Faiz Mohammad, a civil engineer, was caught at Karachi’s airport with batteries and an electrical circuit hidden in his shoes. And list goes on for the coming years, not confined to Middle Easterners and Muslims. Ganbetta and Hertog pointed out the possible reason is that: engineers tend to have combined emotional conservatism and intellectual habits [3].

On the other hand, Martin Rose, the British Council’s senior consultant on the Middle East and North Africa, concluded that science education fails to inculcate critical thinking the way arts teaching do. Typically their minds only search for right and wrong namely in binary. Therefore the engineering students are more susceptible to be recruited by the terrorists [4].

However, most works mentioned above were done by non-Muslims. We believe that the Muslims themselves should play the role to revise the methods of teaching Islamic knowledge to curb the problem of terrorism. Though the contents are adequate, the problem lies in internalizing the true Islamic teachings. Rather than blindly memorising and totally accepting without intellectual discourse, the Muslim students should be allowed to question and discuss so that logical reasoning could take place in their life decision makings. Incorporating Islamic values in the engineering curriculum could also be beneficial for them to balance between the worldly and religious knowledge, thus reducing the inclination towards radicalism.

References

Written by Nur Idawati Md Enzai

1 comment: